Being told you may need robotic prostate surgery can leave you with many questions. A second opinion can help you understand your diagnosis, treatment options and individual risks before making a major decision.
Another specialist may confirm the original recommendation or discuss alternatives such as radiotherapy or active surveillance. You may also want to ask about nerve sparing, cancer control, continence and erectile function, as these decisions can depend on your MRI, biopsy results and overall health.
Why Might You Want a Second Opinion Before Robotic Prostate Surgery?
Robotic radical prostatectomy is a major operation that removes the prostate and usually the seminal vesicles. You may want a second opinion to confirm that surgery is right for you and understand its possible effects on urinary control, sexual function and fertility.
Another prostate cancer surgeon can review your diagnosis and discuss factors such as nerve sparing, cancer control and your likely functional outcomes. A second opinion may simply give you more confidence, or it may help you consider a different approach.
Is Asking for a Second Opinion a Normal Part of Cancer Care?
Yes. Asking for a second opinion is a normal part of making an informed decision about major cancer treatment. You should not feel that it means you distrust your existing medical team.
A second specialist can help you understand the evidence alongside your priorities and concerns. Seeking another specialist opinion can be part of making an informed decision about your treatment.
How Can You Arrange a Second Opinion in the UK?
If you would like a second opinion, you can start by speaking to your current consultant or GP and explaining why another specialist assessment would help you. You may want another surgeon to review your diagnosis, MRI, biopsy results or proposed treatment plan before you decide whether surgery is right for you. Within NHS care, you do not have an automatic legal right to a second opinion, but you can discuss your request with your GP or current consultant, who can explain how another opinion may be arranged.
Before your appointment, it can help to make sure the second specialist has access to your relevant medical information, including your PSA results, biopsy report, MRI images and reports, and details of any previous treatment. You may also find it useful to write down the questions that matter most to you, such as your treatment options, nerve sparing, continence, sexual function and recovery, so you can clearly understand and compare the advice you receive.
What Will a Second Robotic Prostate Surgeon Review?

A second surgeon will review more than your diagnosis. Your PSA history, biopsy results, Gleason score or ISUP Grade Group and the amount and location of cancer can all influence whether surgery is suitable and how it should be planned.
Your MRI is also important for assessing the cancer’s size, position and possible spread beyond the prostate. You should also discuss your general health, urinary function, erections and personal priorities, as these can affect your treatment options.
What May Be Reviewed During a Second Opinion?
| Area reviewed | Why it matters |
| PSA and PSA history | Helps assess your cancer risk and shows how your PSA has changed over time |
| Biopsy and Grade Group | Shows how aggressive the cancer appears |
| MRI findings | Helps assess cancer location and possible spread |
| General health | Helps determine whether surgery is appropriate |
| Urinary and sexual function | Helps set realistic expectations after treatment |
How Do Your Cancer Grade and Risk Group Affect the Advice?
Not every prostate cancer behaves in the same way. Your PSA, biopsy grade, clinical stage and MRI findings help determine your overall risk and whether the cancer is likely to progress.
Surgery is not automatically the best option simply because cancer has been found. A second surgeon can help you understand whether active surveillance, surgery or radiotherapy is more appropriate for your cancer and personal circumstances.
UK Guidance Note
Current UK guidance recommends matching treatment to your prostate cancer risk group and individual circumstances. Depending on your risk group, your options may include active surveillance, radical prostatectomy or radical radiotherapy.
This is why a second opinion should consider your overall risk group rather than recommending surgery simply because prostate cancer has been diagnosed.
Why Is Your Prostate MRI So Important?
Your prostate MRI helps show where the cancer is and whether there are signs it has spread beyond the prostate. This can influence surgical planning, including whether nerve preservation may be appropriate for you.
MRI is not perfect, so your surgeon should consider it alongside your biopsy and other clinical information. A second opinion can give you a fresh assessment of your scan and how it may affect your operation.
Can Your Biopsy Results Change the Surgical Plan?

Yes. Your biopsy shows the grade, location and amount of cancer in your prostate, helping your surgeon assess its behaviour. This information can influence decisions such as whether nerve preservation is suitable for you.
A pathology review may sometimes clarify an uncertain or unusual result and could change your risk assessment. You should consider your MRI, biopsy and PSA together, as each provides different information for planning your treatment.
Could Another Surgeon Decide That You Do Not Need Surgery?
Possibly. A second opinion can help you confirm whether surgery is right for you or whether options such as active surveillance or radiotherapy should be considered. You may find that another surgeon reaches the same recommendation but explains the benefits and risks differently.
There is no single treatment that suits everyone with localised prostate cancer. You should understand the advantages and possible side effects of each option before deciding, so you can feel confident about the treatment you choose.
Evidence Note
Research and UK guidance show that localised prostate cancer can sometimes be managed with active surveillance, surgery or radiotherapy. Each option has different benefits and side effects, so there is no single treatment that is best for every patient.
What Is Nerve-Sparing Robotic Prostate Surgery?
The nerves that help you achieve erections run close to the prostate. During robotic prostate surgery, your surgeon may preserve these nerves on both sides, one side or neither, depending on where your cancer is located.
The priority is to remove the cancer safely while preserving function where possible. You should know that nerve sparing depends on your individual cancer risk, so a second surgical opinion can help you understand whether it may be suitable for you.
Can Two Surgeons Have Different Opinions About Nerve Sparing?
Yes. You may receive different advice because nerve-sparing decisions depend on your MRI, biopsy results, cancer grade, PSA and risk of cancer extending beyond the prostate. A surgeon’s experience and approach can also influence what they consider safely achievable.
One surgeon may recommend preserving nerves on both sides, while another may suggest one-sided nerve sparing. You should ask why each approach is considered appropriate and how it balances your cancer treatment with the possibility of preserving erections.
Does Nerve Sparing Guarantee That Your Erections Will Recover?
No. Nerve sparing can improve the chance of recovering erectile function, but it cannot guarantee normal erections after surgery. Your age, pre-operative erectile function, general health and degree of nerve preservation can all affect recovery, which may take considerable time.
You may be offered medication, vacuum devices or other rehabilitation strategies during recovery. A second surgeon should give you realistic expectations about your individual chances rather than simply saying that your operation will be “nerve sparing”.
How Might the Surgical Technique Differ Between Surgeons?

Robotic prostatectomy does not mean every surgeon performs the operation in exactly the same way. Although the robotic system provides the instruments and visualisation, your surgeon’s technique, experience and judgement influence how different parts of the operation are approached.
- Nerve-sparing approach: Surgeons may differ in how they assess and preserve the nerves responsible for erectile function, depending on your cancer location, MRI and biopsy findings.
- Dissection technique: The way tissues are separated around the prostate can vary according to the surgeon’s preferred method, your anatomy and the extent of your cancer.
- Bladder neck and urethral reconstruction: Surgeons may use different techniques when reconnecting the bladder to the urethra, with the aim of supporting healing and urinary recovery.
- Planning around your individual anatomy: Prostate size, previous abdominal or prostate surgery, body weight and other anatomical factors may influence how your surgeon plans and performs the procedure.
These technical differences do not necessarily mean that one approach is always better than another. During a second opinion, you can ask how the surgeon would approach your individual case and why they believe that technique is appropriate for you.
Will You Need Lymph Nodes Removed During Surgery?
Not everyone having radical prostatectomy needs nearby lymph nodes removed. Your surgeon will consider your PSA, biopsy grade, cancer stage and estimated risk of cancer reaching the lymph nodes.
If lymph node removal is appropriate, it can provide additional information about your cancer. A second surgeon can explain whether you need this procedure, how extensive it may be and why it is recommended for you.
What Should You Ask About Urinary Continence?
Urinary leakage is common after radical prostatectomy, especially when your catheter is removed, but your bladder control usually improves as you recover. Your age, existing urinary function, pelvic floor strength, anatomy and surgical factors can affect your recovery, and some men may have persistent incontinence requiring further treatment.
During a second opinion, ask how the surgeon measures continence and what their reported rate actually means. You should ask whether being “continent” means using no pads, one security pad or another definition, so you can understand your expected outcome and compare your surgeon’s results fairly.
What Should You Ask About Sexual Function?
Sexual recovery after radical prostatectomy involves more than erections. You will no longer ejaculate semen after radical prostatectomy because the prostate and seminal vesicles are removed. This means natural conception through sexual intercourse is generally no longer possible, even if you later regain erections and can still experience orgasm. If having children in the future matters to you, ask about sperm storage before surgery.
You should also ask whether bilateral, unilateral or no nerve sparing is planned and how this may affect your erectile recovery. When discussing percentages, ask how they apply to you, as your pre-operative erections and degree of nerve preservation can significantly influence your outcome.
Should You Ask About the Surgeon’s Experience and Results?
Yes. Robotic technology is a tool, but your surgeon’s experience and judgement remain important. You can ask how many prostatectomies they perform, how often they carry out nerve-sparing surgery and how they monitor their results.
You should also ask how outcomes are measured, including cancer control, positive surgical margins, complications, continence and erectile recovery. Looking at several measures gives you a clearer picture than relying on one headline success rate when choosing your surgeon.
Research Insight
Studies suggest that higher surgeon and hospital case volumes for radical prostatectomy may be associated with better outcomes in areas such as surgical margins and peri-operative complications. However, case numbers should not be considered alone, as outcomes can vary between individual surgeons and centres.
What Questions Should You Ask During a Second Opinion?

A second consultation is most useful when you understand why a particular treatment is recommended. You can ask whether the surgeon agrees with your cancer stage and risk assessment, has reviewed your MRI and considers surgery the best option for you. You should also ask about the risk of cancer outside the prostate and whether bilateral or unilateral nerve sparing is realistic.
Discuss whether lymph node removal is expected, the surgeon’s continence and functional results, catheter duration and your expected recovery. You can also ask what follow-up will involve and what further treatment might be needed if your final pathology shows more extensive cancer than expected.
Myth vs Fact
| Myth | Fact |
| Asking for a second opinion means you distrust your doctor. | A second opinion can simply help you feel more confident about a major treatment decision. |
| Every prostate cancer needs immediate surgery. | Some localised cancers may be suitable for active surveillance or another treatment. |
| Nerve-sparing surgery guarantees normal erections. | Nerve sparing may improve the chance of recovery, but it cannot guarantee erectile function. |
| Robotic surgery is performed the same way by every surgeon. | Surgical planning and technique can vary between surgeons. |
| A second opinion will always recommend something different. | Another specialist may agree completely with your original treatment plan. |
Key Takeaways
- A second opinion can help confirm whether robotic prostate surgery is appropriate for you.
- Your PSA, biopsy, Grade Group, MRI and overall health should be considered together.
- Nerve sparing depends on cancer location and the risk of disease extending outside the prostate.
- Surgery is not automatically the best treatment for every localised prostate cancer.
- Continence and erectile-function results vary between patients and surgeons.
- Ask how your surgeon defines and measures their reported outcomes.
- A second opinion should help you understand your choices rather than simply provide another recommendation.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why should you get a second opinion before robotic prostate surgery?
A second opinion can help you confirm your diagnosis and understand whether surgery is the best option for you. Another specialist may also discuss alternatives such as radiotherapy or active surveillance.
2. What will another prostate surgeon review?
Your surgeon may review your PSA, biopsy results, Gleason score or ISUP Grade Group, MRI and cancer stage. They will also consider your general health, urinary function and erectile function.
3. Could a second opinion mean you do not need surgery?
Yes, another specialist may recommend an alternative such as active surveillance or radiotherapy. They may also agree that surgery is appropriate but explain your options differently.
4. Can two surgeons have different opinions about nerve sparing?
Yes, nerve-sparing decisions depend on your MRI, biopsy results, PSA and cancer location. One surgeon may recommend bilateral nerve sparing, while another may advise preserving nerves on one side.
5. Does nerve-sparing surgery guarantee erectile function?
No, nerve sparing can improve your chances of erectile recovery but cannot guarantee it. Your age, pre-operative erections, health and degree of nerve preservation can all affect recovery.
6. Should you ask about your surgeon’s experience?
Yes, you should ask how frequently your surgeon performs robotic prostate surgery and nerve-sparing procedures. You can also ask how they measure outcomes such as cancer control, continence and erectile recovery.
7. What should you ask about urinary continence?
You should ask about the surgeon’s continence results and how they define being continent. Your recovery can depend on factors including your age, existing urinary function and surgical factors.
8. What should you ask about sexual function?
You should ask how your planned nerve-sparing approach may affect your chances of erectile recovery. You should also discuss fertility, as radical prostatectomy means you will no longer ejaculate semen, so natural conception through sexual intercourse is generally no longer possible. If future fertility matters to you, discuss sperm storage before treatment.
9. Will you need lymph nodes removed during surgery?
Not everyone needs lymph node removal during robotic prostate surgery. Your PSA, biopsy grade, cancer stage and risk of lymph-node involvement help determine whether it is recommended for you.
10. What questions should you ask during a second opinion?
You can ask whether the surgeon agrees with your diagnosis, cancer stage and treatment plan. You should also discuss nerve sparing, continence, erectile function, lymph node removal, recovery and possible further treatment.
Final Thoughts: Making an Informed Decision About Robotic Prostate Surgery
A second opinion before robotic prostate surgery can help you better understand your diagnosis, treatment options and likely outcomes. You can discuss important factors such as nerve sparing, cancer control, continence and erectile function before making your decision.
If you are considering a prostate cancer second opinion in London, you can contact our team to discuss your options and arrange a consultation tailored to your individual needs.
References:
- Stępka, J. et al. (2026) ‘Contemporary Preoperative Detection of Extraprostatic Extension in Prostate Cancer’, Cancers, 18(3), article 456. Available at: https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6694/18/3/456
- Liu, Y. et al. (2023) ‘Erectile Function, Urinary Continence and Oncologic Outcomes of Neurovascular Bundle Sparing Robot-Assisted Radical Prostatectomy for High-Risk Prostate Cancer: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis’, Frontiers in Oncology, 13, article 1161544. Available at: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10113629/
- Radhakrishnan, A. et al. (2017) ‘Second Opinions from Urologists for Prostate Cancer: Who Gets Them, Why, and Their Link to Treatment’, Cancer, 123(6), pp. 1027–1034. Available at: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28263389/
- Hamdy, F.C. et al. (2023) ‘Fifteen-Year Outcomes after Monitoring, Surgery, or Radiotherapy for Prostate Cancer’, The New England Journal of Medicine, 388(17), pp. 1547–1558. Available at: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36912538/
- Van den Broeck, T. et al. (2021) ‘A Systematic Review of the Impact of Surgeon and Hospital Caseload Volume on Oncological and Nononcological Outcomes After Radical Prostatectomy for Nonmetastatic Prostate Cancer’, European Urology, 80(5), pp. 531–545. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0302283821002980
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) (2019, updated 2021) Prostate cancer: diagnosis and management (NG131). Available at: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng131
- Royal Free London NHS Foundation Trust (2026) Changing your NHS hospital doctor or asking for a second opinion. Available at: https://www.royalfree.nhs.uk/patients-and-visitors/patient-information-leaflets/changing-your-nhs-hospital-doctor-or-asking-second-opinion