If you are comparing Aquablation with robotic prostate surgery, you should know that they are usually used for different prostate problems. Aquablation treats urinary symptoms from an enlarged prostate, while robotic radical prostatectomy removes the prostate to treat suitable prostate cancer.
For you, the choice depends on why you need treatment. If you have BPH without prostate cancer requiring treatment, your urologist may discuss Aquablation. If you have suitable localised or locally advanced prostate cancer, radical prostatectomy may be one of the treatment options discussed.
What Is Aquablation?
If you have urinary symptoms from an enlarged prostate, your urologist may discuss Aquablation as a treatment option. Your surgeon uses ultrasound guidance and a high-pressure water jet to remove selected prostate tissue blocking your urine flow.
For you, Aquablation does not remove your whole prostate. Your prostate remains in place, which makes it very different from robotic radical prostatectomy used to treat suitable prostate cancer.
UK Guidance Note
NICE states that transurethral water-jet ablation can be used to treat lower urinary tract symptoms caused by benign prostate enlargement when standard arrangements are in place for clinical governance, consent and audit. NICE concluded that there is good-quality evidence that the procedure improves urinary symptoms and is sufficiently safe for this use.
For prostate cancer, NICE separately recommends considering robotic surgery for localised prostate cancer and emphasises that treatment decisions should take account of cancer risk and the person’s treatment options. Aquablation guidance for BPH should therefore not be interpreted as guidance for treating prostate cancer.
What Is Robotic Radical Prostatectomy?
If you have suitable prostate cancer, robotic radical prostatectomy may be used to remove your prostate and usually your seminal vesicles. Your surgeon may also remove pelvic lymph nodes depending on your cancer risk and controls the robotic instruments from a console through small abdominal incisions.
For you, the robot does not remove your prostate on its own. Your surgeon makes the key decisions, including whether nerve-sparing is suitable and whether lymph nodes need to be removed, before reconnecting your bladder to your urethra.
What Conditions Do the Two Procedures Treat?
If you have BPH, Aquablation may remove obstructing prostate tissue to improve your urinary symptoms. If you have suitable prostate cancer, robotic radical prostatectomy removes the prostate as cancer treatment.
For you, the key difference is your diagnosis: Aquablation treats benign enlargement, while radical prostatectomy treats suitable prostate cancer.
Aquablation vs Robotic Radical Prostatectomy
| Feature | Aquablation | Robotic radical prostatectomy |
| Main condition treated | Benign prostate enlargement/BPH causing urinary symptoms | Suitable prostate cancer |
| Main aim | Improve urine flow and urinary symptoms | Remove the prostate containing cancer |
| How it is performed | Through the urethra using image-guided high-pressure waterjet ablation | Through small abdominal access points using surgeon-controlled robotic instruments |
| Whole prostate removed? | No | Yes |
| Seminal vesicles removed? | No | Usually yes |
| Abdominal incisions | No | Usually several small access sites |
| Ejaculation afterwards | May be preserved, but ejaculatory changes can occur | Semen ejaculation is lost after prostate and seminal-vesicle removal |
| Main evidence outcomes | Urinary symptoms, urine flow, ejaculation and retreatment | Cancer control, PSA, continence, complications and erectile function |
| Cancer treatment? | No | Yes, when radical prostatectomy is appropriate |
Why Can BPH and Prostate Cancer Be Confused?

If you have urinary symptoms, it does not necessarily mean you have prostate cancer. BPH and prostate cancer can affect the same organ and occur at similar ages, but they are different conditions, and you can have both at the same time.
For you, BPH commonly causes urinary obstruction, while early prostate cancer may cause no symptoms. Your urologist may therefore investigate for cancer before BPH treatment and consider both conditions when discussing your treatment options.
Clinical Tip
Urinary symptoms alone cannot tell you whether you have BPH or prostate cancer. Your specialist may consider factors such as your PSA, examination findings, prostate size, age, family history and, when appropriate, MRI or biopsy results before deciding which treatment pathway is suitable.
This is particularly important before comparing Aquablation with cancer treatment, because treating urinary obstruction does not itself treat an underlying prostate cancer.
How Does Aquablation Actually Remove Prostate Tissue?
If you have Aquablation, your surgeon uses ultrasound to plan the area to treat before a high-pressure water jet removes the prostate tissue blocking your urine flow. The technique is non-thermal, so your surgeon does not rely on heat to remove the tissue.
For you, the treatment is carefully planned and controlled by your surgeon. Your surgeon may manage bleeding afterwards using techniques such as diathermy or catheter traction.
Evidence Note
Five-year studies show that improvements after Aquablation can be maintained over time. In the WATER randomised trial, urinary symptom scores remained substantially improved at five years, and procedure-related ejaculatory dysfunction was reported less often after Aquablation than after TURP.
The WATER II study followed patients with larger prostates of 80–150 ml and also found sustained improvements in urinary symptoms and flow at five years. Approximately 96% remained free from another surgical BPH procedure at five years, although these population-level results cannot predict an individual patient’s outcome.
How Does Robotic Prostatectomy Remove the Prostate?
If you have robotic prostatectomy, your surgeon reaches your prostate through small abdominal incisions rather than through your urethra. Your surgeon separates and removes the prostate and seminal vesicles, and may also remove nearby lymph nodes if needed.
For you, the prostate is completely removed, so your bladder must then be reconnected to your urethra. You will usually have a temporary catheter while this connection heals.
Does Aquablation Remove the Whole Prostate?
No. If you have Aquablation for BPH, your surgeon removes selected prostate tissue that is blocking your urine flow while leaving the rest of your prostate in place.
For you, this means Aquablation is designed to improve urinary symptoms, not treat prostate cancer. Your prostate therefore remains after the procedure, unlike robotic radical prostatectomy.
Does Robotic Prostatectomy Remove the Whole Prostate?

Yes. If you have robotic radical prostatectomy, your surgeon removes your whole prostate and usually your seminal vesicles to treat prostate cancer. The removed tissue can then be examined to understand your cancer more fully.
After your prostate is removed, your PSA should become very low or undetectable. You will no longer ejaculate semen, and these changes result from prostate removal rather than the robot itself.
How Do the Technologies Differ?
If you have Aquablation, imaging helps your surgeon map the tissue to remove, while the system delivers a controlled water jet according to that plan. Your surgeon still plans the treatment and controls the procedure.
With robotic prostatectomy, your surgeon continuously controls the camera and instruments from a console. For you, the robot does not remove your prostate automatically; it helps your surgeon perform precise movements during the operation.
Which Procedure Is More Invasive?
If you compare the two, robotic radical prostatectomy is more extensive because your whole prostate is removed and your bladder is reconnected to your urethra. Your surgeon may also remove lymph nodes.
For you, Aquablation is a less extensive procedure because your surgeon treats prostate tissue through your urethra without abdominal incisions or removing the whole prostate. It can still cause bleeding, infection or temporary urinary problems.
How Does Recovery After Aquablation Compare With Robotic Prostatectomy?
If you have Aquablation, your early recovery mainly involves your prostate and urinary tract. You may have a catheter and temporary blood in your urine, urgency or discomfort.
After robotic prostatectomy, your abdominal wounds and bladder-to-urethra connection need time to heal. For you, urinary leakage and erectile changes can also occur as you recover.
How Do the Procedures Affect Ejaculation and Sexual Function?

If you have Aquablation, your ejaculation may be better preserved than with some other BPH procedures, although changes can still occur. Your erectile function is generally a separate consideration.
After robotic prostatectomy, you will no longer ejaculate semen because your prostate and seminal vesicles are removed. For you, erections may also be affected, although nerve-sparing may help when it is safe for your cancer.
Could Aquablation Be Used Instead of Prostatectomy for Prostate Cancer?
If you have prostate cancer, Aquablation is not designed to eradicate it or replace radical prostatectomy when surgery is appropriate. Aquablation treats urinary blockage from BPH rather than the cancer itself.
Your prostate cancer treatment may include surgery, radiotherapy or active surveillance. You should discuss your cancer risk and treatment options with your specialist rather than choosing Aquablation because it is less invasive.
What If You Have BPH and Prostate Cancer at the Same Time?
If you have both BPH and prostate cancer, your treatment will depend on which condition needs attention and your individual cancer risk.
- Cause of your urinary symptoms: Your specialist will consider whether your symptoms are caused by BPH, prostate cancer or another urinary problem.
- Your cancer risk: The stage and risk of your prostate cancer can influence whether monitoring or active cancer treatment is appropriate.
- Treating urinary obstruction: If BPH is causing troublesome blockage, your urologist may discuss treatment while continuing to monitor your cancer when appropriate.
- Prostatectomy may address both problems: If robotic prostatectomy is suitable for your cancer, removing the prostate also removes the enlarged prostate tissue, although urinary symptoms can have other causes.
Your specialist will consider both conditions together before recommending treatment, rather than treating your urinary symptoms or cancer in isolation.
How Does the Evidence for Aquablation Compare With the Evidence for Robotic Prostatectomy?
If you have BPH, Aquablation studies focus on urinary symptoms, urine flow, ejaculation and retreatment. Robotic prostatectomy studies focus on cancer control, PSA, continence and erectile function.
For you, this means the procedures cannot be judged by one overall success rate because they treat different conditions.
Research Insight
Aquablation trials generally measure outcomes such as urinary symptom scores, maximum urine flow, ejaculation and the need for repeat BPH treatment. Five-year studies have shown sustained symptom and flow improvements across prostate sizes ranging from approximately 30 to 150 ml.
Radical prostatectomy research asks different questions because it is a cancer treatment. Outcomes include PSA control, recurrence, surgical margins, urinary continence, erectile function and longer-term cancer outcomes. Comparing the two procedures simply by recovery time or “success” would therefore be misleading because they are designed to achieve different clinical goals.
Which Procedure Might You Actually Need?

If you have BPH causing troublesome urinary symptoms, you may discuss Aquablation or other BPH treatments with your urologist. If you have prostate cancer, your options may instead include active surveillance, radiotherapy or robotic prostatectomy, depending on your cancer.
For you, the appropriate procedure depends on your diagnosis, prostate and cancer findings, and personal priorities. If you are considering robotic prostate surgery in London, you should discuss whether prostatectomy is appropriate for your cancer.
Myth vs Fact
| Myth | Fact |
| Aquablation and robotic prostatectomy are two ways of treating the same problem. | They usually treat different conditions: Aquablation treats BPH symptoms, while radical prostatectomy treats suitable prostate cancer. |
| Aquablation removes the whole prostate. | It removes selected obstructing tissue while leaving the prostate in place. |
| Aquablation can replace prostatectomy for prostate cancer. | Aquablation is not intended to eradicate prostate cancer. |
| Robotic prostatectomy is performed automatically by a robot. | The surgeon controls the instruments and makes the surgical decisions. |
| Aquablation always preserves ejaculation. | Ejaculatory dysfunction is less common than with some BPH operations, but it can still occur. |
| Radical prostatectomy only affects cancer and not sexual function. | Loss of ejaculation is expected, and erectile function can also be affected. |
Key Takeaways
- Aquablation treats urinary symptoms from BPH, while robotic radical prostatectomy treats suitable prostate cancer.
- Aquablation removes selected obstructing tissue; radical prostatectomy removes the whole prostate and usually the seminal vesicles.
- Aquablation is performed through the urethra, while robotic prostatectomy usually uses small abdominal access points.
- Aquablation may preserve ejaculation more often than some BPH procedures, although changes can still occur.
- After radical prostatectomy, semen ejaculation is lost and erectile function may also be affected.
- Aquablation is not intended to replace radical prostatectomy as prostate cancer treatment.
- Your diagnosis, symptoms, cancer risk and treatment priorities should guide which treatment is appropriate for you.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What Is the Difference Between Aquablation and Robotic Prostate Surgery?
Aquablation and robotic radical prostatectomy usually treat different prostate problems. Aquablation treats urinary symptoms caused by BPH, while robotic prostatectomy removes the prostate to treat suitable prostate cancer.
2. What Is Aquablation Used For?
Aquablation is a treatment for urinary symptoms caused by an enlarged prostate. Your surgeon uses ultrasound guidance and a high-pressure, non-thermal water jet to remove selected prostate tissue blocking your urine flow.
3. What Is Robotic Radical Prostatectomy Used For?
Robotic radical prostatectomy may be used to treat suitable prostate cancer. Your surgeon removes your whole prostate and usually the seminal vesicles, with pelvic lymph-node removal considered depending on your cancer.
4. Does Aquablation Remove the Whole Prostate?
No. Aquablation removes selected tissue causing urinary obstruction while leaving the rest of your prostate in place. For you, this means it is designed to improve BPH symptoms rather than treat prostate cancer.
5. Does Robotic Prostatectomy Remove the Whole Prostate?
Yes. Your surgeon removes the whole prostate and usually the seminal vesicles during radical prostatectomy. Your bladder is then reconnected to your urethra, and you will usually have a temporary catheter while the connection heals.
6. Can Aquablation Be Used Instead of Prostatectomy for Prostate Cancer?
Generally, no. Aquablation is designed to treat prostate tissue causing urinary blockage from BPH, rather than remove prostate cancer with the aim of treating the tumour.
7. How Do Aquablation and Robotic Prostatectomy Differ in Surgical Extent?
Robotic radical prostatectomy is more extensive because your whole prostate is removed through abdominal incisions and your bladder is reconnected to your urethra. Aquablation is performed through your urethra without abdominal incisions, although it can still cause bleeding, infection and temporary urinary problems.
8. How Does Recovery Differ Between Aquablation and Robotic Prostatectomy?
After Aquablation, your early recovery mainly involves your urinary tract, and you may experience temporary blood in your urine, urgency or discomfort. After robotic prostatectomy, your abdominal wounds and bladder-to-urethra connection need to heal, and urinary leakage or erectile changes can occur during recovery.
9. How Do Aquablation and Robotic Prostatectomy Affect Sexual Function?
With Aquablation, ejaculation may be better preserved than with some other BPH procedures, although changes can still occur. After robotic prostatectomy, you will no longer ejaculate semen because your prostate and seminal vesicles are removed, while erectile function may also be affected despite nerve-sparing when suitable.
10. What If You Have Both BPH and Prostate Cancer?
Your treatment depends on which condition needs treatment and your individual findings. If robotic prostatectomy is suitable for your cancer, removing your prostate may also relieve urinary obstruction, but your specialist should establish whether your symptoms are caused by BPH, cancer or another urinary problem.
Final Thoughts: Which Prostate Treatment May Be Suitable for You?
Aquablation and robotic prostate surgery treat different prostate problems. If you have BPH, Aquablation may be discussed; if you have suitable prostate cancer, robotic radical prostatectomy may be one of your treatment options.
If you are considering robotic prostate surgery in London and would like specialist advice, you can contact our team to discuss your treatment options and arrange a consultation tailored to your individual needs.
References:
- Hughes, T., Harper, P. and Somani, B.K. (2023) ‘Treatment Algorithm for Management of Benign Prostatic Obstruction: An Overview of Current Techniques’, Life, 13(10), article 2077. Available at:
https://www.mdpi.com/2075-1729/13/10/2077 - Gilling, P.J., Barber, N., Bidair, M., Anderson, P., Sutton, M., Aho, T., Kramolowsky, E., Thomas, A., Kaufman, R.P. Jr, Badlani, G., Plante, M., Desai, M., Doumanian, L., Te, A.E. and Roehrborn, C.G. (2022) ‘Five-year outcomes for Aquablation therapy compared to TURP: results from a double-blind, randomized trial in men with LUTS due to BPH’, The Canadian Journal of Urology, 29(1), pp. 10960–10968. Available at:
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35150215/ - Bhojani, N., Bidair, M., Kramolowsky, E., Desai, M., Doumanian, L., Zorn, K.C., Elterman, D.S., Kaufman, R.P. Jr, Eure, G., Badlani, G., Plante, M., Uchio, E., Gin, G., Paterson, R., So, A., Roehrborn, C., Motola, J., Kaplan, S. and Humphreys, M. (2023) ‘Aquablation Therapy in Large Prostates (80–150 mL) for Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms Due to Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia: Final WATER II 5-Year Clinical Trial Results’, The Journal of Urology, 210(1), pp. 143–153. Available at:
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12721682/ - National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) (2026) ‘Transurethral water-jet ablation for lower urinary tract symptoms caused by benign prostatic hyperplasia’, HealthTech guidance HTG691. Available at: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/htg691
- Xu, M.-Y., Zeng, N., Ma, S., Hua, Z.-J., Zhang, S.-H., Xiang, J.-C., Xiong, Y.-F., Xia, Z.-Y., Sun, J.-X., Liu, C.-Q., Xu, J.-Z., An, Y., Wang, S.-G. and Xia, Q.D. (2024) ‘A clinical evaluation of robotic-assisted radical prostatectomy (RARP) in localized prostate cancer: A systematic review and network meta-analysis’, Critical Reviews in Oncology/Hematology, 204, article 104514. Available at:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1040842824002579 - Wang, J., Hu, K., Wang, Y., Wu, Y., Bao, E., Wang, J., Tan, C. and Tang, T. (2023) ‘Robot-assisted versus open radical prostatectomy: a systematic review and meta-analysis of prospective studies’, Journal of Robotic Surgery, 17(6), pp. 2617–2631. Available at:
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37721644/ - Liu, Y., Deng, X.-Z., Qin, J., Wen, Z., Jiang, Y., Huang, J., Wang, C.-J., Chen, C.-X., Wang, L., Li, K.-P., Wang, J.-H. and Yang, X.-S. (2023) ‘Erectile function, urinary continence and oncologic outcomes of neurovascular bundle sparing robot-assisted radical prostatectomy for high-risk prostate cancer: A systematic review and meta-analysis’, Frontiers in Oncology, 13, article 1161544. Available at:
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10113629/